
Andrew Shotland
Founder and CEO, Local SEO Guide
Local SEO Guide
At a Glance
- Role
- Founder and CEO of Local SEO Guide, Pleasanton, California
- Founded
- 2006
- Earlier
- GM of NBC.com and a founding member of InsiderPages
- Known for
- Local SEO tests on reviews, citations, and AI visibility
From InsiderPages to a 20-Year Agency
Local SEO Guide grew from a solo consultant focused on local marketplaces and local businesses into a team of more than 20. Its clients range from Walmart to single-location businesses, a span that gives him an unusual view of what works at both ends of the market.
In a September 2026 podcast, marking close to 20 years as CEO, he joked that his brother still asks every year whether the business will keep going and whether he will ever get a real job.
Talk to the Machine
He thinks AI visibility is mostly old work. “The key things are really just like SEO: get your content correct on your site, targeting whatever it is someone's searching for in AI,” he said in September 2026. “With SEO, we were always trying to go to the customer through the machine. I don't think it's any different with LLMs.”
His rule for content follows from that: the first five sentences are for the LLMs, and the rest is for the person who arrives at the site. He also tells owners to ask AI what they charge, since a competitor's page or a Reddit thread may list the wrong price.
Reviews, Citations, and a Six on Every Side
In a summer study with Local Falcon across several million local queries, his team found that ChatGPT's local answers drew on Bing, Foursquare, Yelp, TripAdvisor, BBB, and best-of lists, with no Google review data at all. More reviews lifted AI visibility on Google and ChatGPT up to about 200, then leveled off.
He explains citations with a die. Pages that mention both plumbing and Pleasanton are candidates to be sources, and each listing is a side of the die. Put the same attributes, such as water heater replacement, on every listing, and “you have a six, six chance,” he said in November 2026. Our ChatGPT local search study tests similar patterns.
Rankings Up, Calls Down
His most sobering case is a franchise client with 100 locations whose rankings rose 20 to 30 percent year over year while clicks and calls fell about 40 percent. He cannot yet say whether AI Overviews, more ads, or lower demand is to blame. A personal injury firm that stopped Google ads because it could not make the math work lost most of its leads.
His experiments also show what does not last. A Reddit brand-mention test lifted AI visibility almost at once, then faded when posting stopped, and cheap self-issued best-of releases fell back to zero. Real press in Business Insider and Reuters gave a client a lift for about three weeks. Earned attention lasts longer than tricks in his tests, the same pattern he has tracked in local search since 2006.