
Andy Crestodina
Co-founder and CMO, Orbit Media Studios
Orbit Media Studios
At a Glance
- Role
- Co-founder and chief marketing officer, Orbit Media Studios
- Founded
- Orbit Media in Chicago, Illinois, in 2001
- Author
- Content Chemistry: The Illustrated Handbook for Content Marketing, seventh edition
- Teaching
- Co-instructor at Northwestern University and up to 100 talks a year
Building Orbit Media in Chicago
He co-founded Orbit Media in 2001 and has led its strategy and marketing since, with a focus on analytics, SEO, and website optimization, as his team page describes. Along the way he wrote Content Chemistry: The Illustrated Handbook for Content Marketing, now in its seventh edition, and became a fixture on content marketing influencer lists.
He also teaches, as a co-instructor at Northwestern University and a digital marketing instructor at Harbour.Space University, and gives up to 100 presentations a year. Outside the agency he is a certified Treekeeper with Openlands and helped found Chicago Cause, which has donated more than $800,000 in digital marketing services to Chicago nonprofits.
Questioning the AI Search Checklist
He recently ran an experiment on his own industry. He used a tool to scan 150 articles about AI search optimization on SEO blogs and found they agreed on five recommendations: FAQ blocks, schema and llms.txt, third-party mentions, Reddit and community presence, and frequent updates. “I worry that SEOs are often over-relying on checklists and tools without thinking creatively or strategically,” he wrote in What SEOs Get Wrong About AI Search. “And in this case, I’m skeptical of the best practices themselves.”
Sales Calls as a Source of Questions
His alternative starts with a company's own data. Instead of generating FAQs from keyword tools, he suggests exporting sales call transcripts, which he calls “huge piles of language directly from your target audience,” and asking an AI tool which questions prospects ask most and which they hesitate to ask. He put 65 transcripts into NotebookLM for his own test, because it sticks closely to the source material, to get his prospects' own words back.
The Orbit Media blog has since published citation research of its own, including a study of 13,184 AI citations across ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Perplexity, which found that the four engines agreed on the same cited domain for the same question only 1.7 percent of the time. Our listicle citation rate research looks at the same question from another angle.
The Same Advice, Applied to AI
His AI advice sounds like his advice from 2001: understand the audience better than competitors, publish what only you can publish, and measure the result. The difference now is that the reader deciding whether a page is useful might be a language model, and he wants marketers to answer it with their customers' words, not a checklist. Buyers comparing agencies on that standard can start with our highest-reviewed GEO and AEO agencies.