
Barry Adams
Founder, Polemic Digital
Polemic Digital
At a Glance
- Role
- Founder, Polemic Digital
- In SEO since
- 1998
- Specialty
- SEO and audience growth for news publishers
- Also
- Co-founder, News & Editorial SEO Summit; Ulster University lecturer
Polemic Digital and the News Desk
Polemic Digital describes itself as a no-nonsense business that gives clients a straight answer, and its work centers on SEO and audience growth for publishers. He also co-founded the News & Editorial SEO Summit, the first conference devoted to SEO for news, lectures on Ulster University's MSc in Digital Marketing Communication and Leadership, and speaks at Pubcon, SMX, BrightonSEO, and Friends of Search, as the Polemic Digital about page lists.
Counting the Lost Clicks
In March 2026 he answered questions from Australia's ABC on whether his earlier warning had come true. In mid-2025 he had said “extinction” was too strong a word for what would happen to websites and that “decimation” was the right one. “Pretty much, yes,” he replied. “Search traffic to websites is diminishing gradually as Google injects AI Overviews into more search results.”
He put numbers on it. AI Overviews showed on 43 percent of Google queries in the UK and 38 percent in the US, and when one appears, the click-through rate on the top organic result drops from an average of 27 percent to 11 percent. “Google search traffic is truly zero-sum,” he wrote. “If your competitor gets the click, you don’t.” Our publisher AI licensing deal statistics show how publishers are pricing the content AI now summarizes.
Commodity News Loses, Live Coverage Wins
His view is that the hardest-hit publishers rewrite what others report. AI Overviews summarize those stories and leave no reason to click, while breaking news, hyperlocal stories, detailed analysis, and original perspective hold up better. “The one thing that AI can’t duplicate is live coverage,” he said in a fireside chat for the SEO for Journalism newsletter.
He is skeptical of GEO for publishers. A content site that lives on page views gains little when its reporting is read inside a chatbot, he argued in the same conversation. Ecommerce is different: “If you’re e-commerce, yes, optimize for LLMs. Go for it,” he said, because shoppers now start buying journeys by asking a chatbot. Our AI citation freshness statistics cover how often those answers reach for recent pages.
Every Click Counts
He sees a hard reset with an upside. Publishers grew used to Google as an endless source of traffic; now each visit has to be earned and respected. In his telling, the era of clickbait is “well and truly dead,” and the publishers that already invested in brand authority are calm while the rest catch up.
The consultant who has spent nearly three decades on search now tells newsrooms the same thing he told them before AI: be the source worth citing, and give the reader a reason to come to the site itself.