
Carolyn Shelby
Principal SEO, Yoast
Yoast
At a Glance
- Role
- Principal SEO at Yoast
- Practice
- CSHEL Search Strategies
- First company
- Co-founded an early commercial ISP in 1994
- Speaking
- International speaker on search since 2007
Building the Early Web
Shelby co-founded one of the first commercial ISPs in 1994. “At the time, we were writing our own web server software and working directly with the constraints of early network and protocol design,” she has written.
She says that work gave her a systems-first habit: study how behavior comes out of architecture, incentives, and constraints. She later moved into enterprise SEO and large-scale publishing roles before joining Yoast.
GEO as an Extension of SEO
In 2026 she put the overlap plainly. “The same practices that make content discoverable and trustworthy for search engines also make it usable for LLMs,” she said. “In reality, LLM visibility rewards clarity, relevance, and authority, all long-standing SEO principles.”
She gave food bloggers the same message in November 2026: keep sites crawlable, put key facts in text, and lean on firsthand experience so AI tools have a reason to cite you. Our schema markup research looks at one of those machine-readable signals.
Say It the Same Way Everywhere
Shelby sees mixed messaging as a growing risk. When a website, product pages, social profiles, and third-party sources tell slightly different stories, “the brand becomes harder to describe and easier to distrust,” she has said.
She also worries about AI-written content that readers find tiring, since people stop sharing and citing it. “Models don't reward good writing directly; they absorb how the world reacts to it,” she said. Her test for 2026 is discipline: “knowing who you are, saying it clearly, and saying it the same way everywhere.” Our AI brand misinformation statistics show what happens when that slips.