Joy Hawkins
Owner and President, Sterling Sky
Sterling Sky
At a Glance
- Role
- Owner and president of Sterling Sky
- Team
- Close to 50 people serving local businesses only
- Community
- Founder of the Local Search Forum and a Google Product Expert
- Known for
- More than a thousand local ranking tests
A Thousand Tests in the Local Pack
Hawkins has spent close to two decades studying local results and has run more than a thousand tests on what moves rankings for local businesses. She is also a Product Expert on Google's official forums, which puts her in front of real problems from business owners every week.
Her first advice is patience. When a change shows up in the results, she said in September 2026, it is often wiser to wait a week or two to see whether it is a stable trend or a temporary swing. Many fluctuations settle back on their own within days. Our ChatGPT local search study shows how much those answers can move.
Stable Rankings, Fewer Calls
Many local owners now see steady rankings and falling phone calls. Ranking reports will not explain that, she says. Changes in results page features will: more ads, larger ads with more features, and fewer call buttons in mobile results, which together cut click-to-calls from the local pack.
Sterling Sky now counts a call as a lead only if it lasts at least 30 seconds, or two minutes in some industries, and holds monthly revenue check-ins with clients. “There are a lot of businesses that will have less traffic and their leads are fine, or their revenue is fine,” she said in July 2026.
The AI Lead Reality Check
Her agency's data cuts against the rush into AI chat tools. “The data does not show anything that justifies the effort people are putting into AI,” she said. AI leads, in her words, are “tiny, a fraction of what Google provides.” AI Overviews do take informational traffic, and that hurts law firms more than plumbers, because legal explainers drive real leads.
The channel she sees growing is video. “YouTube is the one that is freaking exploding,” she said. “People sleep on it because it's hard, it takes forever, and you can't do it easily.” For multi-location brands, expanding home services firms, and statewide law practices, her view is blunt: “For any lawyer, you should be on YouTube. Hands down.”
Reviews, Reddit, and Consensus
To be cited by AI answer engines, she says, a business needs consensus across sources outside its own site, which is why PR, Reddit, and YouTube now belong in local strategy. She is also blunt about abuse: bought Reddit comments, she said, are not very different from fake reviews, and she has seen a wave of coordinated review attacks.
Her test for an attack is volume. Many negative reviews in a short window, some mentioning contact with the company, point to organized action, sometimes followed by a reputation firm offering to remove them. Our agencies with the most client reviews show the other side of that coin: reviews earned over years, which is the kind of proof she spends her career defending.