
Cyrus Shepard
Founder, Zyppy
Zyppy
At a Glance
- Role
- Founder, Zyppy
- Base
- Oregon
- Previously
- Lead SEO and audience development lead, Moz
- Known for
- AI citation ranking factors research
A Wine Business and Moz
Shepard found SEO in 2009 and liked that it let him reach people at the moment they were looking, without a hard sell. His first client was a wine business that grew from $500,000 to $2.5 million in sales in a single year, as Zyppy's about page recounts.
In 2010 he joined Moz, the SEO software company Rand Fishkin cofounded, and was soon promoted to Lead SEO. His first MozCon talk came in 2011, and in 2013 he took over Moz's audience development team. He left to form Fazillion Media, a content and affiliate business, in 2016, and started Zyppy in 2018.
Ranking Factors for AI Citations
In 2026 Shepard set out to sort what drives AI citations from what people only claim. “I went through and combed dozens and dozens of studies,” he said on the BuzzStream podcast. He found about 75 papers and studies, kept close to 50 that held up, and hand-classified their findings into a set of 23 factors.
Two results stood out. The top factor is whether AI systems can reach a URL at all, a real problem because many sites block AI crawlers without knowing it, as our AI crawler blocking research shows. The next is how well a page ranks for the main query and for the fan-out queries AI tools run in the background. llms.txt showed no measurable link to citations.
Opting Out to Measure
Shepard then tested Google's AI features on his own site. On September 1, 2026, he used Search Console's control to remove Zyppy from AI Overviews and AI Mode, and he opted back in on September 29. Comparing the two periods on the same queries, he estimated that AI features produced about 21 percent of the site's Google clicks, or 23 percent counting a small lift in regular listings, in a write-up of the test.
He also measured a click-through rate of about 0.9 percent on AI impressions against roughly 0.4 percent across the site's search results. He was careful with the claim, asking readers to treat the numbers “more as a directional yardstick than Google gospel.”
Still Betting on Rankings
For all the AI work, his advice stays close to the basics. “It’s great to be in the AI overviews, and you probably should. Great to have citations. But the number one metric to correlate with business success is still the top of the organic rankings,” he said on The Redirect Podcast. Our GEO ROI benchmarks give buyers a way to weigh the two.
Zyppy also runs Zyppy List, a weekly-updated directory of vetted SEO professionals. It fits the habit that started with that wine client in 2009: test the idea, publish the result, and send people to whoever can help.