
At a Glance
- Role
- Founder and CEO of Growth Plays
- Clients
- B2B dev tools, data engineering, and fintech companies
- Team
- Nine people, including Directors of AI, Editorial, and Technical SEO
- Known for
- The retrieval to recommendation ladder for AI visibility
Bold Moves for B2B Search
His long-running argument is that most software companies play content too safe. “Bold moves get bold results,” he said on The Content Cocktail Hour in May 2025, where he made the case that SEO still works when it is tied to revenue, and that earned media and coined frameworks travel further than safe how-to posts.
That same month he led a Demand Gen Council for Scale Venture Partners on why traditional SEO methods were starting to break down. The venture firm introduced him as one of the most honest minds in the field, which is a fair summary of how he talks to clients.
Was SEO Content Ever Good?
In a July 2026 conversation with Ross Hudgens of Siege Media, he took a contrarian line on AI writing. With the right context, he argued, AI already gets a team 85 to 90 percent of the way to a strong B2B article, and the real skill is taking a B+ draft to an A+.
He flipped the industry's favorite complaint. The bar for SEO content was always low, he said, and it took removing humans from the process for anyone to start caring about sentence construction at all. He also warned that AI turns C players into more prolific C players, not A players.
Cited Is Not Recommended
In August 2026 he and Camden Gaspar published a study of buyer's guides, built on Lily Ray's analysis of 100 “best software” queries. Of the AI Overviews that cited a brand's own self-promotional list, 69 percent left that brand out of the recommendations. In 224 of 323 citations, the publisher was not recommended.
“Being cited and being recommended are two separate actions for an LLM,” they wrote. They laid out a ladder: retrieved, cited, mentioned, and recommended. The top rung, they argue, reflects what forums, video, review sites, press, and analysts say about a brand. Our listicle citation rate study measures the same list format from another angle.
What a Smaller Brand Should Do
His advice is not to stop publishing buyer's guides. For a category leader such as Atlan, a guide helps shape how the whole category gets described. For an early-stage company, the same page can act as a vote for competitors, because the model pulls those rivals from it and leaves the publisher out.
The fix, in his view, is the slow work of earning third-party validation: review sites, analyst coverage, forum discussion, and press. “Are we credible enough to be recommended?” is the question he wants every brand to ask, the same plain test his agency applies to its own reporting for CFOs.
Links
Sources
Portrait of John-Henry Scherck.
- Our Approach to Buyer's Guides and Featuring Competitors in Content, Growth Plays, August 2026
- Was SEO Content Ever Good? JH Scherck on the AI Slop Debate, Siege Media, July 2026
- What Great SEO Looks Like Today with JH Scherck, The Content Cocktail Hour, May 2025
- SEO strategy in the age of AI, ScaleVP Demand Gen Council, May 2025
- Growth Plays team